Socrates

The Socratic Method
to Develop Critical Thinking

SOCRATES is an AI that answers your reasoning with questions, aimed at what you have not yet examined.

Guided Scenarios take 8 to 15 minutes and end with five scores. Open Dialogue starts from your own question and is not scored.

What the five scores look at

Assumption Awareness
Evidence Evaluation
Perspective Flexibility
Logical Consistency
Metacognitive Reflection

How SOCRATES Uses the Socratic Method

You pick one of eighteen scenarios, or bring a claim of your own, and say what you think. SOCRATES asks more than it tells. Its first replies draw out your position, and later ones press where it is weakest. A small label over each reply names the move it makes. The sixth and last reply looks back at how your view moved. A separate reading of the whole conversation then scores your reasoning on the five dimensions above, from 1.0 to 5.0, once for where you started and once for where you ended. It also picks out the moments where your reasoning shifted. Open Dialogue asks the same kind of questions about a subject you choose. It has no fixed length and keeps no score.

One Claim, Two Questions

You
The data is clear. More police, less crime. That proves the policy works.
S
Evidence Challenge What would you need to know before treating that as proof rather than correlation?
You
I would need to know what else changed during the same period, whether crime was already falling, and how it compares with similar cities.
S
Meta-Cognitive Mirror Those are the right questions. Why did you not ask them before calling the article proof?

From First Take to Five Scores

1 Engage

A scenario worth thinking about

The eighteen scenarios turn on ethics, strategy, evidence, and logic. You read one and say what you make of it.

Sample Stimuli
Evidence & Causation

A city reports a 30% crime drop after expanding police presence. Your team calls it proof the policy works.

Ethical Reasoning

Your company's AI hiring tool is 15% more accurate but produces racially disparate outcomes.

Strategic Thinking

Your startup's biggest competitor just raised $50M and pivoted into your core market.

Live Session
You
The data is clear. More police, less crime. That's how deterrence works.
S
Evidence Challenge You said "the data is clear." The article gives you one number: a 30% drop. What would you need to know before concluding that police presence was the cause rather than one factor among several?
You
I guess I'd need to know if other things changed: economic conditions, reporting methods, seasonal patterns...
S
Meta-Cognitive Mirror Those are the right questions. So why didn't you ask them before forwarding the article as "proof"? What made you skip straight past them the first time?
2 Question

Six Ways to Ask

SOCRATES looks for the soft spot in what you just said and asks about it. Each question is one of six kinds, named below.

3 Measure

Five Scores, Before and After

When the six exchanges are done, the conversation is read again as a whole and scored from 1.0 to 5.0 on each dimension, at the start and at the end. Only what you wrote counts.

Assumption Awareness Do they see what they're taking for granted?
Evidence Evaluation Can they tell strong evidence from weak?
Perspective Flexibility Do they engage with opposing views?
Logical Consistency Do their conclusions follow from their premises?
Metacognitive Reflection Can they observe their own reasoning?
Post-Session Analysis
Assumption Awareness 2.3 → 2.7 +0.4
Evidence Evaluation 2.1 → 2.8 +0.7
Perspective Flexibility 2.5 → 2.6 +0.1
Logical Consistency 2.8 → 3.1 +0.3
Metacognitive Reflection 1.9 → 2.3 +0.4
Session Insight

"You moved from taking a correlation as proof of cause to naming three confounding variables. Evidence Evaluation shows the largest gain."

The Six, by Name

Assumption Probe

It digs out the belief your argument rests on. "What are you assuming must be true for that to hold?"

Evidence Challenge

It asks whether your evidence can carry your conclusion. "What would change your mind?"

Perspective Shift

It sends you to the other side of the argument. "How would someone with the opposite experience see this?"

Implication Mapping

It follows your claim to where it leads. "If that's true, what else must be true? Are you comfortable with all of it?"

Precision Press

It pins down vague words. "You said 'most people.' How many? On what basis?"

Meta-Cognitive Mirror

It shows you your own reasoning at work. "You changed your position twice. What triggered each shift?"

Built to Support Critical Thinking

Most software now offers to think for you. It will summarize what you meant to read and draft what you meant to write.

SOCRATES turns that around. It asks, and you think.

From Athens to Your Browser

2,400 Years Ago

A stonemason's son in Athens wrote nothing down. He asked people what they believed and why, and kept asking until the reasoning gave way.

Now

A language model can hold up its end of a conversation on almost any subject. SOCRATES uses that ability to ask rather than to answer.

New Umbrella

Building SOCRATES requires three disciplines in combination: Socratic pedagogy and reasoning education, computational linguistics and language model systems, and cognitive science. The founding team works at their intersection. The six intervention types derive from formal study of argumentation theory. The validation strategy reflects fluency with educational research methodology and psychometric standards. The architecture reflects direct experience with language model behaviour across prompt design, output evaluation, and model calibration.

We believe one of the best uses of this technology is to help people think better for themselves.

The unexamined life is not worth living.
Socrates, in Plato's Apology

Claims on Hold

Our Approach

The planned studies use established tests, among them the Watson-Glaser Critical Thinking Appraisal, rather than measures of our own.

Five Cognitive Dimensions

After each guided session, SOCRATES scores five dimensions of reasoning from 1.0 to 5.0:

Assumption Awareness:Identifying unstated beliefs
Evidence Evaluation:Distinguishing correlation from causation
Perspective Flexibility:Engaging with opposing views
Logical Consistency:Internal coherence of arguments
Metacognitive Reflection:Observing your own reasoning

Help Build SOCRATES

What We Look For

SOCRATES draws on three fields: Socratic teaching, language models, and cognitive science. What you can do and how you think matter more than your title.

We are especially keen to hear from people in computational linguistics, educational psychology, the evaluation of language models, or full-stack engineering. Other backgrounds are welcome too.

No role is open at the moment.

Send a note explaining what you'd build and why to:

[email protected]

Privacy Policy

Last updated: March 2026

What We Collect

When you use SOCRATES, we collect the email address you provide at signup, your dialogue session transcripts (for scoring and improvement), and basic usage data (session timestamps, completion rates). We do not collect personal information beyond what you voluntarily provide.

How We Use Your Data

Your session data is used to generate cognitive scores, track your progress over time, and improve the SOCRATES dialogue system. We do not sell your data. We do not share identifiable data with third parties. Aggregate, anonymised data may be used in published research.

Data Storage and Security

Your data is stored on secure, encrypted servers. Session transcripts may be processed by third-party model providers solely to provide the service, subject to their applicable data-processing terms.

Your Rights

You may request access to, correction of, or deletion of your personal data at any time by contacting [email protected]. We will respond within 30 days.

Cookies and Analytics

SOCRATES uses only essential cookies required for the application to function, plus privacy-respecting product analytics (PostHog) to understand how the system is used. We never record full prompts, transcripts, spoken content, email addresses, or other personal content. We record only safe metadata such as page views, named button clicks, mode (typed or voice), message counts, and event types. We do not use advertising cookies, autocapture, or session-replay tools.

Contact

For privacy-related inquiries: [email protected]

Terms of Service

Last updated: March 2026

Service Description

SOCRATES is an educational reasoning-practice application that uses Socratic questioning to support critical thinking practice. It is not a substitute for professional education, therapy, or mental health treatment.

Acceptable Use

You agree to use SOCRATES for its intended purpose: reasoning practice through structured Socratic dialogue. You agree not to attempt to reverse-engineer, copy, or redistribute the system, its prompts, or its scoring methodology.

Intellectual Property

All content, methodology, scoring systems, intervention frameworks, and interface designs are the intellectual property of Noetic Profectus Ltd. Your session transcripts remain yours; the system's responses, scoring algorithms, and analytical methods remain ours.

Beta Program

SOCRATES is currently in beta. The service is provided as-is during the beta period. Features, scoring methods, and availability may change. We will provide reasonable notice before any material changes.

Limitation of Liability

SOCRATES is an educational reasoning-practice tool, not a diagnostic instrument. Cognitive scores are designed to track relative improvement, not to assess clinical capacity. Noetic Profectus Ltd. is not liable for decisions made based on SOCRATES scores or feedback.

Contact

For questions about these terms: [email protected]

Data Protection

Last updated: March 2026

GDPR Compliance

Noetic Profectus Ltd. is committed to compliance with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). We process personal data only with lawful basis, typically consent or legitimate interest in providing our service.

Data Minimization

We collect only the data necessary to provide the SOCRATES service: your email, session transcripts, and cognitive scores. We do not collect location data, device fingerprints, or browsing history.

Data Processing

Session transcripts may be processed by third-party model providers solely to provide the service, subject to their applicable data-processing terms. We do not use your identifiable session transcripts to train third-party AI models. De-identified or aggregate session data may be used to improve, evaluate, and validate SOCRATES, as described in this policy. Third-party model processing is governed by the applicable provider terms.

Data Retention

While an account is active, its data is retained to deliver the service and to track progress over time. When an account is deleted, its personal data is removed within 30 days. Anonymized, aggregate data may be retained for research purposes.

Your Rights Under GDPR

You have the right to: access your data, rectify inaccuracies, request erasure, restrict processing, data portability, and object to processing. To exercise any right, contact [email protected].

Data Protection Officer

For data protection inquiries: [email protected]

Your Turn to Answer

Start a session

News, Now and Then

Expect an occasional email about new scenarios, product changes, and the planned studies.